
u/Taco_Pie
I bought a Forerunner 945 in February of 24. In January of 25 I had to get a new one because it failed. Service was great about it. Now in June of 26 it failed again. Customer service just shrugged me off. There is a blanket return option for a refurbished for $140 which appears to be my only option.
So I have burned through a watch a year, each failing despite normal use, and my only option is to buy another refurbished at a slight discount.
This is pretty frustrating, are these watches really only supposed to be good for a year? I thought they had a reputation for a good life and that customer support was strong.

u/Caymancaptain
This will be my second Garmin watch that has broken within a month or so of purchasing it.
The first I had to ship back to the place of purchase (at my cost) for a refund through original place of purchase since Garmin support was less than helpful with warranty replacement.
Regrettably now, I went ahead and decided to give Garmin another chance and purchased a Marq Captain Gen 2 watch for almost $3,000 and this one also stopped working within 2 months. Garmin is telling me they no longer stock this watch and therefore can’t fix or replace it. Instead Garmin is offering me a much lower priced model. I won’t be able to use this model as it lacks water ingress protection which was the original reason I purchased this Marq watch. They do have a new model (gen 3) of the Marq watch but have refused my request to have this model as a replacement.
At this point, I really do not want another Garmin product as I have had a terrible experience with their customer support. This is quite distressing since I probably have close to $100,000 worth of Garmin Marine products between my two charter boats and would hate for them to refuse to honor a warranty replacement on any of these products.
If this is Garmin’s stance, I requested that they “exchange the device for a full refund” which is an alternative under their warranty.

u/Hurls_33
Got a few scratches on my FR970 after 18 days of very very light use (literally just being worn around the house and at work). Reached out to Garmin Support and they're willing to do a full, free of cost, exchange with a new watch. Amazing.
This is my second watch now and certainly won't be my last.

u/Macieq
I bought my first Garmin watch a little over 2 years ago, and it genuinely changed how I train. It pushed me harder than I used to push myself and became a big part of my routine. I actually grew to like that “tough love” style of motivation.
I’ve been recommending Garmin to people around me, and I know for a fact at least two of my friends bought their watches partly because of my influence, and I even got one for my mum last Christmas.
Fast forward to about two weeks ago. Just a few days after the warranty expired. After a workout, the watch started flashing, tried to reboot, got stuck on the triangle logo… and then just died completely. It wasn't an aftermath of any accident it just died randomly, while being on my hand.
Of course I contacted Garmin support. After 4 days and three attempts, they finally replied and offered me a replacement with a 50% discount. Which, sure, could be worse. They didn’t have to offer anything.
But at the same time… 50% off is still more than what some competitors like Coros, or Polar charge for a brand new watch.
And honestly, the timing couldn’t be worse. It died right after warranty, and right when I don’t have spare cash to take that offer anyway, good thing that the offer is valid for 60 days.
What frustrates me isn’t even the experience itself, because up until now, it was great. It’s the fact that I’ve been actively recommending Garmin to others, and now I feel kinda guilty for it. It leaves me wondering if this is just bad luck on my part… or something closer to planned obsolescence.

u/Icy-Fox7490
So, very disappointing actions by Garmin. My fenix 7X fails to properly deliver the audio prompts. It’s a safety enhancement feature, which would allow me to not look at my watch but hear pace , heartrate, etc through the earphones, but it just does that for a while and then stops working after a random nr of steps. Often the audio prompts just plain stop, but also often the entire stream of ‘missed prompts’ pours in after the run actually is over, for minutes in a row… somehow it gets buffered or so. Weird, annoying, not at all safe. And mostly annoying that a part of a 1000 euro watch just fails. Watch bought June 2022, issue notified to Garmin in November 2023 (within warranty), but their email reply basically only said ‘was solved, restart watch’, no investigation whatsoever! As the issue randomly appears, isn’t always present, it appeared solved but wasn’t. Issue resurfaced October 2024, again notified to Garmin. Somehow Garmin USA picked this up, did thoroughly investigate and concluded ‘watch needs replacement ‘. Living in Belgium, Garmin BE needs to action this. Their reply: out of warranty, you can have a refurbished replacement, at cost of 260 euro!!

u/Taco_Pie
I bought a Forerunner 945 in February of 24. In January of 25 I had to get a new one because it failed. Service was great about it. Now in June of 26 it failed again. Customer service just shrugged me off. There is a blanket return option for a refurbished for $140 which appears to be my only option.
So I have burned through a watch a year, each failing despite normal use, and my only option is to buy another refurbished at a slight discount.
This is pretty frustrating, are these watches really only supposed to be good for a year? I thought they had a reputation for a good life and that customer support was strong.

u/Caymancaptain
This will be my second Garmin watch that has broken within a month or so of purchasing it.
The first I had to ship back to the place of purchase (at my cost) for a refund through original place of purchase since Garmin support was less than helpful with warranty replacement.
Regrettably now, I went ahead and decided to give Garmin another chance and purchased a Marq Captain Gen 2 watch for almost $3,000 and this one also stopped working within 2 months. Garmin is telling me they no longer stock this watch and therefore can’t fix or replace it. Instead Garmin is offering me a much lower priced model. I won’t be able to use this model as it lacks water ingress protection which was the original reason I purchased this Marq watch. They do have a new model (gen 3) of the Marq watch but have refused my request to have this model as a replacement.
At this point, I really do not want another Garmin product as I have had a terrible experience with their customer support. This is quite distressing since I probably have close to $100,000 worth of Garmin Marine products between my two charter boats and would hate for them to refuse to honor a warranty replacement on any of these products.
If this is Garmin’s stance, I requested that they “exchange the device for a full refund” which is an alternative under their warranty.

u/Hurls_33
Got a few scratches on my FR970 after 18 days of very very light use (literally just being worn around the house and at work). Reached out to Garmin Support and they're willing to do a full, free of cost, exchange with a new watch. Amazing.
This is my second watch now and certainly won't be my last.

u/Macieq
I bought my first Garmin watch a little over 2 years ago, and it genuinely changed how I train. It pushed me harder than I used to push myself and became a big part of my routine. I actually grew to like that “tough love” style of motivation.
I’ve been recommending Garmin to people around me, and I know for a fact at least two of my friends bought their watches partly because of my influence, and I even got one for my mum last Christmas.
Fast forward to about two weeks ago. Just a few days after the warranty expired. After a workout, the watch started flashing, tried to reboot, got stuck on the triangle logo… and then just died completely. It wasn't an aftermath of any accident it just died randomly, while being on my hand.
Of course I contacted Garmin support. After 4 days and three attempts, they finally replied and offered me a replacement with a 50% discount. Which, sure, could be worse. They didn’t have to offer anything.
But at the same time… 50% off is still more than what some competitors like Coros, or Polar charge for a brand new watch.
And honestly, the timing couldn’t be worse. It died right after warranty, and right when I don’t have spare cash to take that offer anyway, good thing that the offer is valid for 60 days.
What frustrates me isn’t even the experience itself, because up until now, it was great. It’s the fact that I’ve been actively recommending Garmin to others, and now I feel kinda guilty for it. It leaves me wondering if this is just bad luck on my part… or something closer to planned obsolescence.

u/Icy-Fox7490
So, very disappointing actions by Garmin. My fenix 7X fails to properly deliver the audio prompts. It’s a safety enhancement feature, which would allow me to not look at my watch but hear pace , heartrate, etc through the earphones, but it just does that for a while and then stops working after a random nr of steps. Often the audio prompts just plain stop, but also often the entire stream of ‘missed prompts’ pours in after the run actually is over, for minutes in a row… somehow it gets buffered or so. Weird, annoying, not at all safe. And mostly annoying that a part of a 1000 euro watch just fails. Watch bought June 2022, issue notified to Garmin in November 2023 (within warranty), but their email reply basically only said ‘was solved, restart watch’, no investigation whatsoever! As the issue randomly appears, isn’t always present, it appeared solved but wasn’t. Issue resurfaced October 2024, again notified to Garmin. Somehow Garmin USA picked this up, did thoroughly investigate and concluded ‘watch needs replacement ‘. Living in Belgium, Garmin BE needs to action this. Their reply: out of warranty, you can have a refurbished replacement, at cost of 260 euro!!

u/Taco_Pie
I bought a Forerunner 945 in February of 24. In January of 25 I had to get a new one because it failed. Service was great about it. Now in June of 26 it failed again. Customer service just shrugged me off. There is a blanket return option for a refurbished for $140 which appears to be my only option.
So I have burned through a watch a year, each failing despite normal use, and my only option is to buy another refurbished at a slight discount.
This is pretty frustrating, are these watches really only supposed to be good for a year? I thought they had a reputation for a good life and that customer support was strong.

u/Caymancaptain
This will be my second Garmin watch that has broken within a month or so of purchasing it.
The first I had to ship back to the place of purchase (at my cost) for a refund through original place of purchase since Garmin support was less than helpful with warranty replacement.
Regrettably now, I went ahead and decided to give Garmin another chance and purchased a Marq Captain Gen 2 watch for almost $3,000 and this one also stopped working within 2 months. Garmin is telling me they no longer stock this watch and therefore can’t fix or replace it. Instead Garmin is offering me a much lower priced model. I won’t be able to use this model as it lacks water ingress protection which was the original reason I purchased this Marq watch. They do have a new model (gen 3) of the Marq watch but have refused my request to have this model as a replacement.
At this point, I really do not want another Garmin product as I have had a terrible experience with their customer support. This is quite distressing since I probably have close to $100,000 worth of Garmin Marine products between my two charter boats and would hate for them to refuse to honor a warranty replacement on any of these products.
If this is Garmin’s stance, I requested that they “exchange the device for a full refund” which is an alternative under their warranty.

u/Hurls_33
Got a few scratches on my FR970 after 18 days of very very light use (literally just being worn around the house and at work). Reached out to Garmin Support and they're willing to do a full, free of cost, exchange with a new watch. Amazing.
This is my second watch now and certainly won't be my last.

u/Macieq
I bought my first Garmin watch a little over 2 years ago, and it genuinely changed how I train. It pushed me harder than I used to push myself and became a big part of my routine. I actually grew to like that “tough love” style of motivation.
I’ve been recommending Garmin to people around me, and I know for a fact at least two of my friends bought their watches partly because of my influence, and I even got one for my mum last Christmas.
Fast forward to about two weeks ago. Just a few days after the warranty expired. After a workout, the watch started flashing, tried to reboot, got stuck on the triangle logo… and then just died completely. It wasn't an aftermath of any accident it just died randomly, while being on my hand.
Of course I contacted Garmin support. After 4 days and three attempts, they finally replied and offered me a replacement with a 50% discount. Which, sure, could be worse. They didn’t have to offer anything.
But at the same time… 50% off is still more than what some competitors like Coros, or Polar charge for a brand new watch.
And honestly, the timing couldn’t be worse. It died right after warranty, and right when I don’t have spare cash to take that offer anyway, good thing that the offer is valid for 60 days.
What frustrates me isn’t even the experience itself, because up until now, it was great. It’s the fact that I’ve been actively recommending Garmin to others, and now I feel kinda guilty for it. It leaves me wondering if this is just bad luck on my part… or something closer to planned obsolescence.

u/Icy-Fox7490
So, very disappointing actions by Garmin. My fenix 7X fails to properly deliver the audio prompts. It’s a safety enhancement feature, which would allow me to not look at my watch but hear pace , heartrate, etc through the earphones, but it just does that for a while and then stops working after a random nr of steps. Often the audio prompts just plain stop, but also often the entire stream of ‘missed prompts’ pours in after the run actually is over, for minutes in a row… somehow it gets buffered or so. Weird, annoying, not at all safe. And mostly annoying that a part of a 1000 euro watch just fails. Watch bought June 2022, issue notified to Garmin in November 2023 (within warranty), but their email reply basically only said ‘was solved, restart watch’, no investigation whatsoever! As the issue randomly appears, isn’t always present, it appeared solved but wasn’t. Issue resurfaced October 2024, again notified to Garmin. Somehow Garmin USA picked this up, did thoroughly investigate and concluded ‘watch needs replacement ‘. Living in Belgium, Garmin BE needs to action this. Their reply: out of warranty, you can have a refurbished replacement, at cost of 260 euro!!

u/Taco_Pie
I bought a Forerunner 945 in February of 24. In January of 25 I had to get a new one because it failed. Service was great about it. Now in June of 26 it failed again. Customer service just shrugged me off. There is a blanket return option for a refurbished for $140 which appears to be my only option.
So I have burned through a watch a year, each failing despite normal use, and my only option is to buy another refurbished at a slight discount.
This is pretty frustrating, are these watches really only supposed to be good for a year? I thought they had a reputation for a good life and that customer support was strong.

u/Caymancaptain
This will be my second Garmin watch that has broken within a month or so of purchasing it.
The first I had to ship back to the place of purchase (at my cost) for a refund through original place of purchase since Garmin support was less than helpful with warranty replacement.
Regrettably now, I went ahead and decided to give Garmin another chance and purchased a Marq Captain Gen 2 watch for almost $3,000 and this one also stopped working within 2 months. Garmin is telling me they no longer stock this watch and therefore can’t fix or replace it. Instead Garmin is offering me a much lower priced model. I won’t be able to use this model as it lacks water ingress protection which was the original reason I purchased this Marq watch. They do have a new model (gen 3) of the Marq watch but have refused my request to have this model as a replacement.
At this point, I really do not want another Garmin product as I have had a terrible experience with their customer support. This is quite distressing since I probably have close to $100,000 worth of Garmin Marine products between my two charter boats and would hate for them to refuse to honor a warranty replacement on any of these products.
If this is Garmin’s stance, I requested that they “exchange the device for a full refund” which is an alternative under their warranty.

u/Hurls_33
Got a few scratches on my FR970 after 18 days of very very light use (literally just being worn around the house and at work). Reached out to Garmin Support and they're willing to do a full, free of cost, exchange with a new watch. Amazing.
This is my second watch now and certainly won't be my last.

u/Macieq
I bought my first Garmin watch a little over 2 years ago, and it genuinely changed how I train. It pushed me harder than I used to push myself and became a big part of my routine. I actually grew to like that “tough love” style of motivation.
I’ve been recommending Garmin to people around me, and I know for a fact at least two of my friends bought their watches partly because of my influence, and I even got one for my mum last Christmas.
Fast forward to about two weeks ago. Just a few days after the warranty expired. After a workout, the watch started flashing, tried to reboot, got stuck on the triangle logo… and then just died completely. It wasn't an aftermath of any accident it just died randomly, while being on my hand.
Of course I contacted Garmin support. After 4 days and three attempts, they finally replied and offered me a replacement with a 50% discount. Which, sure, could be worse. They didn’t have to offer anything.
But at the same time… 50% off is still more than what some competitors like Coros, or Polar charge for a brand new watch.
And honestly, the timing couldn’t be worse. It died right after warranty, and right when I don’t have spare cash to take that offer anyway, good thing that the offer is valid for 60 days.
What frustrates me isn’t even the experience itself, because up until now, it was great. It’s the fact that I’ve been actively recommending Garmin to others, and now I feel kinda guilty for it. It leaves me wondering if this is just bad luck on my part… or something closer to planned obsolescence.

u/Icy-Fox7490
So, very disappointing actions by Garmin. My fenix 7X fails to properly deliver the audio prompts. It’s a safety enhancement feature, which would allow me to not look at my watch but hear pace , heartrate, etc through the earphones, but it just does that for a while and then stops working after a random nr of steps. Often the audio prompts just plain stop, but also often the entire stream of ‘missed prompts’ pours in after the run actually is over, for minutes in a row… somehow it gets buffered or so. Weird, annoying, not at all safe. And mostly annoying that a part of a 1000 euro watch just fails. Watch bought June 2022, issue notified to Garmin in November 2023 (within warranty), but their email reply basically only said ‘was solved, restart watch’, no investigation whatsoever! As the issue randomly appears, isn’t always present, it appeared solved but wasn’t. Issue resurfaced October 2024, again notified to Garmin. Somehow Garmin USA picked this up, did thoroughly investigate and concluded ‘watch needs replacement ‘. Living in Belgium, Garmin BE needs to action this. Their reply: out of warranty, you can have a refurbished replacement, at cost of 260 euro!!